date: Fri Mar 11 08:41:18 2005 from: Phil Jones subject: Re: FW: Application for Fellowship ref 00022570 to: "Althea Howard" Althea, Back in Norwich now. I don't recall meeting this person in Birmingham in 1999. Likely my fault as I meet a lot of people. I only recall 2-3 emails many years ago. I suspect Brian will not recall him either. Looking at his 'application' form, he doesn't have that many real references. He looks to be retired. Being an editor on Climate Research is something I wouldn't put on my CV. It is a discredited journal in the field. Most of the people he puts in the email (the 4 in the US and the other 5 are mainly greenhouse skeptics - although Changnon, Landsea and Pielke are mainstream climatologists). So, I'd be wary of accepting him as a fellow. Mike Hulme isn't at the Hadley Centre, but here at UEA (m.hulme@uea.ac.uk). My only other link with him occurred in late 2003. Usborne books (a British publishing house had a good book for kids (12-14 yr olds)) yet a group of Canadians (including Khandekar) complained to the publishers about the content of one of their series on Global Warming. Usborne got me to read through the book and assess their critical comments, which were groundless. I did think at the time that this was being very petty. Hope this helps in any decision. Cheers Phil At 08:32 09/03/2005, you wrote: Here it is Phil....many thanks. Althea Howard (Ms) Membership, Subscriptions and Accounts Royal Meteorological Society 104 Oxford Road Reading RG1 7LL Tel 0118 9568500, Fax 0118 9568571 membership@rmets.org ___________________________________________________________________________________ From: Madhav Khandekar [[1]mailto:mkhandekar@rogers.com] Sent: 05 March 2005 00:50 To: Althea Howard Subject: RE: Application for Fellowship ref 00022570 Dear Ms Howard During my attendance to IUGG Conference in Birmingham, UK(1999), I met following UK scientists ( only briefly) who would be aware of my research. 1: Dr. Phil Jones, University of east Anglia, UK ( Phil and I have communicated with each other extensively thru e-mails). 2: Prof. Brian Hoskins, University of Reading, UK ( I met and discussed only briefly with Prof. Hoskins during IUGG). During my wave modeling work at Environment Canada, I attended several annual meetings in Europe ( from 1988 thru 1993) and have met a few UK wave modelers. Notable among them are: 1: Ms Rachael Stratton ( she used to work in wave modeling group at UK Met office some 15 years ago. I understand she works at present with climate molders like Dr. Gareth Jones and others at UK Climate Modeling Group). 2: Dr. Peter A.E.M. Janssen, originally from Netherlands, now working on global ocean wave models at ECMWF in Reading, UK. More recently at the Climate Change Conference in Moscow ( July 2004), I met Dr. Mike Hulme, a climate scientist with UK climate modeling Group at Exeter, UK. In my editorial work, I often communicate with several US scientists, notable among them are: 1: Prof. Roger Pielke, Sr, Dept of Atmospheric Science, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO, USA 2: Prof. Robert Balling Jr, Arizona State University, Tempe, Arizona, USA 3: Dr. Stanley Changnon, Climatologist ( Emeritus) at Illinois State Water Survey, USA 4. Dr. Christopher Landsea, Hurricane specialist, NOAA Laboratory, Miami, USA Some of the scientists living elsewhere with whom I often communicate are: 1. Dr. Chris de Freitas, University of Auckland, New Zealand 2. Dr. Vincent Gray, retd. Scientist and IPCC external reviewer, Wellington, New Zealand 3. Prof. Kevin Walsh, University of Melbourne, Victoria, Australia 4. Prof. Nils-Axel Morner, Head, Paleogeophysics & Geodynamics, University of Stockholm, Sweden. 5. Dr. Paul Reiter, Scientist & Head of Insect & Infectious Disease, Pasteur Institute, Paris You may want to find out if some of these scientists are Fellows of RMS and you may be able to obtain a supporting reference on my behalf. For your ready reference and use, I am enclosing a brief bio-data of mine in an electronic form ( [2]File:MLK bio, revised) Let me know if you need any other info in this connection. Thank you Sincerely Madhav Khandekar Unionville, ON, L3R 7Z5 Canada -----Original Message----- From: Althea Howard [[3]mailto:Althea.Howard@rmets.org] Sent: Friday, March 04, 2005 10:30 AM To: mkhandekar@rogers.com Subject: Application for Fellowship ref 00022570 Dear Dr Khandekar, Many thanks for your application, but unfortunately we are not able to arrange sponsors for you. I note that you are a member of both the AMS and CMOS, so if you are acquainted with any members of those Societies I can check to see if they are Fellows of the Royal Met Soc. and you could then approach them as potential sponsors. I look forward to hearing from you again, Best regards, Althea Howard (Ms) Membership, Subscriptions and Accounts Royal Meteorological Society 104 Oxford Road Reading RG1 7LL Tel 0118 9568500, Fax 0118 9568571 membership@rmets.org Prof. Phil Jones Climatic Research Unit Telephone +44 (0) 1603 592090 School of Environmental Sciences Fax +44 (0) 1603 507784 University of East Anglia Norwich Email p.jones@uea.ac.uk NR4 7TJ UK ----------------------------------------------------------------------------