date: Wed, 14 Apr 1999 08:43:48 +0100 from: "Julia Uppenbrink" subject: Mike Mann comments to: , Dear Drs Briffa and Osborn I have received Mike Mann's comments. I suggest the following: I edit the Perspective for style, length, .... and put queries in the places where Mike Mann's comments apply. You can then decide for yourself how you wish to address his comments: As his "review" came in without our asking for it, we will certainly not make addressing his concerns a condition for publication. Some of the comments seem very sensible, but as I say, I leave it up to you to a large extent how you address them in the text and figure. Best regards Julia Uppenbrink ========================================== Dr. Julia Uppenbrink Senior Editor/Perspectives Science (Europe Office) Bateman House, 82-88 Hills Rd Cambridge CB2 1LQ, UK T +44 1223 326 500 F +44 1223 326501 E juppenbrink@science-int.co.uk ==========================================